X
Get Started with TD Direct Investing
Would you like more information?
Hedging in investing: Techniques for securing your financial future
If you’ve ever gone on a trip to somewhere outside Canada, you may have thought about buying travel insurance to protect yourself from an unexpected event. Many do-it-yourself investors do something similar, to protect themselves against sickly markets – in the finance world, that protection is called hedging. Hedging comes with a cost and can limit your upside somewhat, but it could be a way to help hold on to your gains if market volatility spikes.
What is hedging?
Hedging is a method that aims to limit losses by purchasing investments that offer an opposite position to an existing investment in your portfolio. Hedges can often be placed using lower-cost options, futures or other derivatives. A perfect hedge, while rarely attainable, would eliminate all risk of a particular asset by being 100% inversely correlated to its price movements.
Accredited investors – typically high-net-worth investors – may also be able to access more sophisticated strategies in the form of hedge funds. These professionally managed investment vehicles employ complex strategies designed to reduce risk and yield absolute returns that are not tied to any particular benchmark. Although hedge funds can offer investors a way to improve the level of diversification – and at times produce strong returns across market cycles – they can come with barriers to entry, high fees and a relative lack of transparency.
The principle of hedging
Understanding of risk management
Investing is inherently risky, but a hedging strategy could help to mitigate some of this risk. One way to do this is by investing in assets that are inversely correlated, meaning they tend to have the opposite reaction to the same market conditions. That way, if market forces cause one asset to decrease in value, the opposing strategy is likely to become more valuable and offset some losses. Less risk, of course, can mean less reward and the hedges that minimize a loss can also limit potential gains.
Some reasons for hedging
There are several reasons why you might want to hedge your risk. For starters, a hedging strategy could help you offset some of the risk of assets you consider risky to own on their own. A hedging strategy could also help to minimize the losses suffered if the market doesn’t perform as expected or help protect gains on an investment you already hold in your portfolio. Rather than selling the investment outright, an investor might consider adding a hedge to limit any potential losses while allowing them to hold on to the position and capture any additional upside.
What are some different types of hedging?
Financial hedging
Financial hedging involves employing financial instruments to counter some of the risk that accompanies fluctuating interest rates, exchange rates or other factors that can affect a company’s bottom line. A coffee producer, for example, might engage in hedging to protect themselves against future increases in the price of coffee beans, a vital component of their cost of doing business.
Operational hedging
Operational hedging is something businesses will do to mitigate risk to their operations. This could involve diversifying suppliers, using flexible manufacturing processes or locating production facilities in different geographic regions. Although this approach doesn’t directly tie into investing, understanding this form of hedging can help you assess how a business is being run and the steps it’s taking to reduce the impact of operational uncertainties on its performance.
Natural hedging
Natural hedging involves investing in assets that are inherently negatively correlated, such as stocks versus bonds, since they typically move in opposite directions depending on interest rates. Companies can use natural hedges to guard against fluctuating exchange rates. For example, a Canadian business that sells its products south of the border could be at risk of losing some revenue if the exchange rate on the U.S. dollar weakens. A natural hedge to this risk would be to increase sales in Canada or move some production to the U.S.
Cross hedging
Cross hedging is a strategy companies use to guard against market forces, often in instances where there are no futures available for an asset of interest. For example, a technology manufacturer might cross hedge its exposure to rare earth minerals by investing in companies that help mine the commodity or by investing in other assets that correlate positively to the minerals. Ideally, the company will look for an asset that tends to see its price rise and fall in unison with the asset the business needs to operate.
Tactical vs. strategic hedging
Tactical hedging generally refers to financial moves made to address short-term market variables. Strategic hedging, on the other hand, usually means employing standard, long-term strategies.
Benefits of hedging
Hedging with derivatives
If an investor is worried that a particular asset in their portfolio is at risk of decreasing in value, they may want to guard against potential losses. A common way to do this is through the use of derivatives like futures contracts, options contracts and swaps. To decrease the risk of that asset of concern, an investor might consider purchasing a derivative contract known as a “put option” on its shares. Because a put option increases in value when a stock drops below a set price, the derivative essentially offsets some of the risk – and potential losses – of the underlying asset.
Spread hedging
Spread hedging is an options trading strategy that involves identifying related assets or positions that, historically, tend to respond to market changes in a similar way, such as two securities that operate within the same sector. By taking opposing long and short positions in the two assets, an investor is hedging against the spread because an increase in value to one position will, ideally, offset any potential losses in the other. While relatively simple in theory, spread hedging can be complicated in practice and typically requires a deep understanding of market dynamics.
Hedging vs. diversification
Hedging and diversification are two risk-reduction strategies that are often used interchangeably, though they are not the same thing. Hedging involves taking an offsetting position in an attempt to reduce the impact market volatility might have on a single asset. Hedging decreases the risk of an investment, but because of its structure and added cost can also decrease its potential upside.
Diversification, on the other hand, is a way to insulate an entire portfolio by ensuring it contains an appropriate mix of different assets.
Benefits of hedging
- It can help mitigate some risk: Well-placed hedges can reduce some of the risk that comes with investing.
- It can help you protect your gains: By purchasing an offsetting investment to one that has performed well, you can protect some of the gains you have already made, and potentially hold on to an investment longer if you feel it may still offer some upside.
- It can insulate against down markets: Because hedging could minimize losses, you may not feel as sharp a sting during periods of high market volatility.
- It could save time: A few good hedges can allow you to feel comfortable enough to decrease the amount of time you spend monitoring the markets.
Risks and challenges of hedging
- It can eat away at gains: Although hedging can help limit losses, the cost of purchasing offsetting assets can take a bite out of potential gains.
- It can be complex: Hedging strategies can be intimidating for newcomers to investing.
- It may prove unnecessary: If markets keep rising, the time and money you put into hedging could be viewed as unnecessary.
Strategies for hedging
Steps to implement a hedging strategy
Hedging may sound simple in theory, but the range of strategies it includes is complex when applied to the very real assets in your portfolio. Before diving in, it’s important to do your research to ensure you fully understand how it works.
Examples of hedging strategies used by hedge funds
While there are individual hedging strategies you can put in place on your own, there are also investments called hedge funds that apply these strategies to insulate returns from market risk and improve returns. These pooled investments typically use complex trading and risk management strategies to serve high-net-worth investors, though over the last few years, some hedge fund–like mutual funds and exchange-traded funds geared toward the average investor have come to market.
Long only
As the name implies, long-only hedge funds invest in assets the fund manager believes will perform well over time. In this way, these funds are similar to mutual funds, but because hedge funds have different regulatory requirements and are not tied to industry benchmarks, they are able to invest in a wider range of assets, including illiquid, private assets.
Long/short
One of the most common techniques employed by hedge funds, a long/short equity strategy involves holding a mix of long positions that are expected to outperform the market, while also holding some short positions to try and capitalize on assets that the portfolio manager expects will drop in value.
Market neutral
Hedge funds that use a market-neutral strategy attempt to eliminate market risk by holding opposing long and short positions on every asset in their portfolio.
Distressed asset
These hedge funds buy and sell the debt of companies trading at a steep discount. They make money in a variety of ways. In some cases, these funds may decide the discount is worth the risk because they feel the company can still repay its debts. In other instances, the asset manager may use their investment to influence the company and help it to restructure or sell off assets to increase the value of the company.
Event-driven
Hedge funds that use an event-driven strategy seek to turn a profit from significant corporate events, such as a merger or takeover.
Multi-strategy or funds of funds
These funds seek to deliver diversification and profit by investing in a basket of different strategies. They come at an added cost because an investor will have to pay a fee for the manager who selects which strategies to hold in the fund, as well as cover the costs for the underlying funds themselves.
Factors to consider as an investor
Fees involved in hedge funds
Hedge funds are complex investment vehicles that typically have higher fees than what you might expect from mutual funds or exchange traded funds. Some hedge fund strategies are only available to accredited investors, which typically means an investor has a high net worth or has received a high net income for a multiyear period. As well, hedge funds may take what’s known as a “2 and 20” approach when assessing fees, which requires investors to pay a 2% annual management fee and a 20% performance fee that comes out of the fund’s profits (provided it meets a predetermined benchmark).
Transparency
Hedge funds are typically less transparent than mutual funds because they are subject to less-stringent regulatory rules. Also, because these strategies rely on their proprietary investment process, portfolio managers may try to limit how much information they share with investors. In Canada, hedge funds are overseen by the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA), which requires them to provide more transparency.
Size of hedge funds
Opinions vary on how much size affects performance, but some researchers believe the bigger a hedge fund gets, the worse it tends to perform. As the hedge fund grow larger, the thinking goes, managers could have a tendency to turn their focus to asset gathering (and the fees it generates). They may feel less incentive to improve their fund because most of their compensation is tied to an asset-based management fee. This suggests that, as funds grow larger, the amount they pay out in management fees exceeds the size necessary for optimal performance.
Hedge funds investor protections
Hedge funds offer fewer protections to investors than other investment vehicles because they are regulated in a way that allows fund managers to engage in riskier practices. One reason these funds can have such a high barrier to entry is to ensure that their investors can better afford to weather any losses.
FAQs
How can a protective put strategy hedge potential losses?
Put options generally move in the opposite direction as the underlying asset. This means if your underlying asset decreases in value, the put option should increase in value and mitigate some of the losses you would otherwise suffer.
How does options trading hedge transaction use delta?
Delta hedging is a complex trading strategy used by institutional investors. It involves using delta – or the change in the value of an option relative to changes in the price of an underlying asset – to hedge against the risk of an investment.
How is investment risk reduced through hedging?
Hedging reduces the risk of investing because it helps you to protect an asset you already hold by purchasing an offsetting investment. If the asset decreases in value, this offsetting investment will likely increase and help mitigate any losses.
What is the difference between hedging and shorting?
Hedging involves using an offsetting position to minimize your investment risk. Shorting refers to borrowing and then selling shares of an asset because you believe it will decrease in value, allowing you to make money when you buy those shares back at a later date.
Share this article
Related Articles
View our learning centre to see how we're ready to help
Open an account online – it's fast and easy!
Whether you're new to self-directed investing or an experienced trader, we welcome you.